9 Comments
User's avatar
Ranger1221regnaR's avatar

Thank you for this article, I agree with most of what you posited, however, not with the main part of your article, and here is why.

Should Love, and respect be mandated, and if not adhered to, or understood, punished? Do we require, and mandate that our children must love us, or do we in fact earn that love, and respect?

These are the questions that immediately came to mind when I read about the mandating of Patriotism.

Surely Patriotism is Love, and Respect, of one's Country, and its values? As such, it should no more be forced, or mandated, like a narcissist demanding, Love, and Respect, does. Love cannot be forced without dire consequences, and as Patriotism is a Love of Country, and its values, to force that, also brings dire consequences.

If you try to force a child to Love you, that child will grow up secretly, or overtly, hating you, and in the same way, if you try to force Patriotism. those upon whom you force it, will end up hating it, and those mandating it.

On the whole, if a country treats its people well, Patriotism will flow, and grow naturally. Only countries which do not treat their people well, force it, and pay the price for it, in subversive movements, and general apathy, and distrust of the institutions demanding it.

If you are seeing a need to enforce Patriotism in your country Alexander, I put it to you, that either there is a great amount of unpatriotic behaviour from your fellow Russians, which seems highly unlikely from all the sources I have watched, read, and listened to, or you are conflating a few disgruntled ones, with the whole, which still won't be swayed to Patriotism if it is mandated.

I believe the saying that you can please all of the people most of the time, and you can please some of the people, all of the time, but you can't please all of the people, all of the time. Such is human nature, that you will never have 100% agreement, or consensus on everything, nor can a nation have 100% Patriotism, all of the time, from all of the people.

A country can convince people to be patriotic, by reminding people of the benefits that they enjoy from such union, as long as those benefits are neither false, nor lacking. A cohesive, caring society, is a patriotic one, and is one precisely because the majority of its members, and indeed the laws that govern them, are genuinely caring, and on the whole, beneficial to that society.

It is through peer pressure, and kind acts, that a society can convince the less patriotically inclined to be patriotic, but not without understanding why those ones are unpatriotic, and indeed, at times, accepting that some, may never be, no matter how well they are treated.

A good, patriotic society, does not fret about the few, and accepts some aberration, however, not if those who are unpatriotic, break laws, and try to convince others to be unpatriotic. In that case, what they do, is what they should be judged on by their fellow members, and laws.

I will maintain the position, that Patriotism is Love, and respect of country, and its values, and like Love in all its variety, cannot, should not, ever be forced.

I leave you with one more question, as I believe you to be a man who gives credence to such as I am about to ask - Did Jesus ever force anyone to Love him? Or did he lead by example, and by his works, convince people to Love him?

On the whole, if we do good things to each other, are we not moved to reciprocate? The same is, I believe, true of Country, and the nature of Patriotism.

Margaret's avatar

I agree with your comment, that true patriotism is akin to love and respect and as such can't be mandated, it has to be felt from the heart.

I would like to see some concrete examples given for what he means and includes by traditional values, and what kind of penalties exactly. How about rules around marriage which is a traditional value and a legal contract; No fault divorce was established making it very easy to divorce, should this go back to making divorce difficult?

Realist's avatar

"I would like to see some concrete examples given for what he means and includes by traditional values, and what kind of penalties exactly."

Yes, the term 'traditional values' is broad and nebulous.

Realist's avatar

"Therefore, administrative and financial penalties for disregarding traditional values or deliberately and openly rejecting them are an entirely logical measure."

This is extremely problematic in a progressive free society. It constitutes a dogmatic ideology.

Evening. Fall of the day's avatar

"This is extremely problematic in a progressive free society. "

Yes, but it is precisely this belief in Enlightenment-era progress—a notion criticized by Aleksandr Dugin—that will ultimately lead to its own destruction. People living in the West are beginning to sense this, or even feel it firsthand. Aleksandr presents a choice: either patriotism—a love for the land one inhabits and for one’s fellow countrymen whom one wishes to support—or cosmopolitanism, which brings chaos, disorientation, and the disintegration of social bonds. Is this not already visible in the West?

Mark Blocker's avatar

The Founders of these United States of America were ardent nationalists and patriots. It is of course preferable to persuade citizens of the necessity of such a point of view, but it is also necessary to preserve a nation worth fighting and dying for, from a pragmatic standpoint.

M Green's avatar

I am very sorry to see Alexander Dugin resort to this desperate recommendation. He has abandoned the better hope of, say, Putin instantiating patriotism by selfless example and inspiring others to follow suit. I agree that it may be necessary for Russia to crack down on “free speech” and dissent, but this is nothing to be happy about. It may be necessary in the short term—Russia cannot do without it—but it bodes ill for any hopes of a proud, self-sustaining and perdurable culture.

He also shows remarkable naivete about the source of wisdom, thinking that it comes naturally with age, e.g. “Therefore, the fact that young people do not particularly understand traditional values simply means that they do not understand much of anything yet. But this changes with age. After all, they are still children, and they will almost certainly grow wiser.” The older generation of Russians is wiser now than the youth because they grew up in and came to embody a coherent culture and set of values that is no longer part of the maturational education of westernized Russian youth, many of whom are for all practical purposes lost souls who remain incapable of achieving wisdom with age.

Dermot O'Sullivan's avatar

Children don't take much notice of what you say; it's what you do that they notice.

Realist's avatar

Dugin seems to be the Mad Monk's second coming. Rasputin lives!