8 Comments
User's avatar
Tom Wolenski's avatar

One tiny correction. Christianity originated in Jerusalem. Christians were first called Christians in Antioch. Rome became the center of Christendom. The rest is spot on. Ty.

Eleanor's avatar

If Europe did not accepted Russia after the enormous sacrifice it made to contribute to winning WWII, it never will. It reminds me of the saying about insanity is doing the same thing over and over again expecting a different result. Putin has demonstrated his patience with Europe and the West multiple times, in the face of their betrayal - NATO pushing eastward just one of many. In 1992, I might have debated "As Lev Gumilev said back in 1992: “If Russia is to be saved, it will only be as a Eurasian power, and only through Eurasianism.”" but not anymore.

eleni's avatar

I agree with much of what you say, but I question the underlying assumption that Russia needs Europe's acceptance. Why should it? Given the political, economic, cultural, and spiritual crises afflicting much of Western Europe, perhaps the question should be reversed: Europe needs to reconsider its relationship with Russia. Russia's historical identity and civilizational significance do not depend on Western approval. The real question is why Russia should continue seeking validation from a “Europe” whose eroding identity and direction are increasingly and rightfully contested and one facing a rapidly declining influence, disappearing sovereignty, cultural disintegration, and increasingly uncertain civilizational identity?

Eleanor's avatar

💯 agree. My reply was in response to the article about Russia coming “across as them begging to be accepted as part of Europe.” and “Putin’s well-known sympathy for European society…”

eleni's avatar

Europe is a geographical designation, and as history has shown definitely not a guarantee of civilizational continuity. A society cannot claim to embody an ancient inheritance merely because it occupies the territory where that inheritance once flourished. Its legitimacy as a cultural successor depends on what it actually preserves, practices, and transmits. Which at this point is nothing. Zero.

Pedro Teixeira da Mota's avatar

Right..... The decadent globalized and infrahumanized western civilization. "nothing", or, at least, much less than it should carry and nurture....

Analytik's avatar

"However, the Russian insistence on being accepted as the legacy of Rome increasingly comes across as them begging to be accepted as part of Europe."

You beg for that which you do not have. That is not the case, plainly. Russians are Christians, not only, of course, but predominantly.

"And they’re not about to share it with Russia."

You can not give what is not yours to give.

Christendom is not a thing that is possessed, given or shared.

"It would be better for Russia to shed its attempt to be Europe entirely."

Russia has never attempted to be Europe. It simply is. Peter and Catherine the Great's attempts to modernise Europe were no different from other cultural-educational exchanges that took place between western European monarchies and North America. French was the lingua franca of European aristocracy, a custom or practice that was also adopted by Russian aristocrats. One should carefully distinguish political rhetoric and superficial polemics arising from conjectural geopolitical dynamics from objective historical facts. Russia, a European nation, culturally extended Europe into Asia. It was certainly influenced by Asian cultures. That is undeniable. You mentioon Lev Gumilev. Had his fascinating notion of passionarity been expressed in work of the German romantic tradition, nobody would have suspected that a Russian had formulated it. All great Russian writers, philosophers, political leaders, physicists, etc refer to Europa, not as outsiders, but as Christian Europeans.

It should not be forgotten that Russians and Russian Historians refer to the period of Mongol subjugation as "the yoke."

Rosa Maria's avatar

Eurasianism. First time I see this term. You may be right.