Aleksandr Dugin’s invocation of the Kabbalah as “the greatest achievement of the human spirit” raises an interesting question about the source and nature of wisdom within a tradition. The Kabbalah, as a mystical interpretation of the Torah, represents an esoteric pursuit—a quest for hidden meanings and divine mysteries accessible only through disciplined study and spiritual ascent. It is not populist in the sense of being immediately available to the masses; rather, it presupposes hierarchy, initiation, and depth -- all of which support Traditionalist thought.
Christian tradition, particularly in its patristic and ascetic streams, shares this layered approach. While the Gospel is proclaimed openly to all, the deeper mysteries—the Logos, theosis, and the contemplative life—require spiritual formation and grace. Both traditions affirm that wisdom does not arise from mere instinct or “faith in the people,” but from participation in something transcendent: for Kabbalah, the emanations of the divine; for Christianity, union with Christ, the Logos made flesh.
Thus, if populism is framed as mystical faith in the collective, Wieseltier is correct to see a tension. Neither Kabbalah nor historic Christianity locates ultimate wisdom in the crowd but in the divine order that calls individuals upward. The real question is whether modern populism can be reconciled with any authentic tradition—or whether it is, as both traditions might argue, a symptom of the loss of transcendence.
The important contribution of modern populism to the political landscape is its rejection of the left-right paradigm. This certainly fueled the populism in the United States. In Putin's case, it may have been reactionary to the unipolar paradigm after the fall of the Soviet Union.
Η Καμπάλα είναι μία παρερμηνεία τής παρερμηνευμενης Παλαιάς Διαθήκης, καί τό χειρότερο έχουν προσθέσει καί δικές τους ιστορίες. Η Παλαιά Διαθήκη δεν είναι ένα απλό βιβλίο, έχει την εξωτερική ιστορία της αλλά καί την εσωτερική ιστορία,την αληθινή πού υποκρύπτει ότι ακριβώς έχει καί η Ελληνική Παράδοση πού έχει ονομαστεί υποτιμητικά Μυθολογία. Ο Σωκράτης διδάσκει τόν Αλκιβιάδη λέγοντας του ότι οι ποιητές γράφουν υπαινικτικά όπως καί ο κατεξοχήν Θείος ποιητής ο Όμηρος καί επειδή η ποίηση είναι υπαινικτική, είναι για λίγους ανθρώπους. Καί συνέχισε λέγοντας ότι εάν τυχόν ο ποιητής είναι Φαύλος δεν βγαίνει νόημα. Ο Χριστιανισμός έχει ενσωματώσει την Εβραϊκή Παράδοση, την έχει "καταπιεί αμασητη" χωρίς να την έχει ελέγξει ποτέ. Ένα απλό ερώτημα θά υποβάλλω, όποιος θέλει και μπορεί,ας απαντήσει : όταν ο Αβραμ καί η Σάρα μπήκαν στην Αίγυπτο,οι άνθρωποι τού Φαραώ απέσπασαν την Σάρα από τον Αβραμ καί την παρέδωσαν στον Φαραώ. Τί χρειαζόταν ο Φαραώ την Σάρα ? νά τού λύσει τά προβλήματα τού Κράτους ? Απλή ερώτηση νομίζω.
If i met a cannibal in a christian community i would hope he or she might deliberately neutralise their collective soul at least while surveying the territory. While it might be a torment for the magnificent ragnard to be induced for the sake of reality perception to suspend for a while the imperious clamour of his vastly superior collective soul, would that be too much to ask for the sake of continued existence on a planet already seriously damaged by midgets aspiring to the platform shoes of mighty masters?
Pezzo straordinario che denuncia con esemplare chiarezza una delle infinite manipolazioni del pensiero del grande filosofo sociologo e politologo Dugin. Le citazioni a sproposito, per usare un eufemismo, non si contano. E chiunque abbia in testa un neurone ancora funzionante, ne comprende perfettamente il motivo
Agree, appears to be incoherent waffle. If this man is “ Putin’s brain” as the western toady press presents him, he would have been committed years ago instead of of taking Russia from a failed state to a world economic and military power in 20 years. Dugin’s scribblings had absolutely nothing to do with it.
Aleksandr Dugin’s invocation of the Kabbalah as “the greatest achievement of the human spirit” raises an interesting question about the source and nature of wisdom within a tradition. The Kabbalah, as a mystical interpretation of the Torah, represents an esoteric pursuit—a quest for hidden meanings and divine mysteries accessible only through disciplined study and spiritual ascent. It is not populist in the sense of being immediately available to the masses; rather, it presupposes hierarchy, initiation, and depth -- all of which support Traditionalist thought.
Christian tradition, particularly in its patristic and ascetic streams, shares this layered approach. While the Gospel is proclaimed openly to all, the deeper mysteries—the Logos, theosis, and the contemplative life—require spiritual formation and grace. Both traditions affirm that wisdom does not arise from mere instinct or “faith in the people,” but from participation in something transcendent: for Kabbalah, the emanations of the divine; for Christianity, union with Christ, the Logos made flesh.
Thus, if populism is framed as mystical faith in the collective, Wieseltier is correct to see a tension. Neither Kabbalah nor historic Christianity locates ultimate wisdom in the crowd but in the divine order that calls individuals upward. The real question is whether modern populism can be reconciled with any authentic tradition—or whether it is, as both traditions might argue, a symptom of the loss of transcendence.
The important contribution of modern populism to the political landscape is its rejection of the left-right paradigm. This certainly fueled the populism in the United States. In Putin's case, it may have been reactionary to the unipolar paradigm after the fall of the Soviet Union.
Η Καμπάλα είναι μία παρερμηνεία τής παρερμηνευμενης Παλαιάς Διαθήκης, καί τό χειρότερο έχουν προσθέσει καί δικές τους ιστορίες. Η Παλαιά Διαθήκη δεν είναι ένα απλό βιβλίο, έχει την εξωτερική ιστορία της αλλά καί την εσωτερική ιστορία,την αληθινή πού υποκρύπτει ότι ακριβώς έχει καί η Ελληνική Παράδοση πού έχει ονομαστεί υποτιμητικά Μυθολογία. Ο Σωκράτης διδάσκει τόν Αλκιβιάδη λέγοντας του ότι οι ποιητές γράφουν υπαινικτικά όπως καί ο κατεξοχήν Θείος ποιητής ο Όμηρος καί επειδή η ποίηση είναι υπαινικτική, είναι για λίγους ανθρώπους. Καί συνέχισε λέγοντας ότι εάν τυχόν ο ποιητής είναι Φαύλος δεν βγαίνει νόημα. Ο Χριστιανισμός έχει ενσωματώσει την Εβραϊκή Παράδοση, την έχει "καταπιεί αμασητη" χωρίς να την έχει ελέγξει ποτέ. Ένα απλό ερώτημα θά υποβάλλω, όποιος θέλει και μπορεί,ας απαντήσει : όταν ο Αβραμ καί η Σάρα μπήκαν στην Αίγυπτο,οι άνθρωποι τού Φαραώ απέσπασαν την Σάρα από τον Αβραμ καί την παρέδωσαν στον Φαραώ. Τί χρειαζόταν ο Φαραώ την Σάρα ? νά τού λύσει τά προβλήματα τού Κράτους ? Απλή ερώτηση νομίζω.
If i met a cannibal in a christian community i would hope he or she might deliberately neutralise their collective soul at least while surveying the territory. While it might be a torment for the magnificent ragnard to be induced for the sake of reality perception to suspend for a while the imperious clamour of his vastly superior collective soul, would that be too much to ask for the sake of continued existence on a planet already seriously damaged by midgets aspiring to the platform shoes of mighty masters?
Pezzo straordinario che denuncia con esemplare chiarezza una delle infinite manipolazioni del pensiero del grande filosofo sociologo e politologo Dugin. Le citazioni a sproposito, per usare un eufemismo, non si contano. E chiunque abbia in testa un neurone ancora funzionante, ne comprende perfettamente il motivo
🤣 needing to write a thesis defending a sentence just shows how polluted the Duginist brain has become
Agree, appears to be incoherent waffle. If this man is “ Putin’s brain” as the western toady press presents him, he would have been committed years ago instead of of taking Russia from a failed state to a world economic and military power in 20 years. Dugin’s scribblings had absolutely nothing to do with it.