9 Comments
User's avatar
Franz Kafka's avatar

This quote reminds me of the mock trial of Prince Igor in The First Circle by Alexander Solzhenitsyn.

"Postmodernism insists that these disciplines and schools have become mere objects within the postmodern subject, which now possesses absolute interpretive control. All such lines of thought are regarded as surpassed, sublated in the Hegelian sense, and thereby stripped of sovereign interpretative rights. They are only permitted to exist within Postmodernism, according to its rules. Taken on their own, they are not simply outdated but toxic when severed from the postmodern context."

Prince Igor was, as I recall found guilty of Anti Revolutionary Activity. The fact that the rules of the game were entirely unknown to him and all his actions interpreted as a violation of those rules by the prosecution led to some hilarious moments.

I recall one such moment in which an objection was raised by the defence to wit: "How could the Prince have violated the Soviet Criminal Code if Soviets did not yet exist?"

The Prosecution retorted immediately and with great relish: "Aha! But Soviet Law did exist!" and quoted from The Lay of Prince Igor's Campaign (16th Century) - "Red banners wave over Putivl."

The trial ended in a guilty verdict.

It is good to have similar fun with Postmodernism and their quasi-Fascistic claims of being 'The Law' and thus above all laws and critiques, past, present and future. How soon fashionable theories turn into sacred cows.

David Denny's avatar

I am trying to learn about this "Postmodernism" thing. My vice is oversimplification, but is it not correct to understand that this "Postmodernism" thing is in fact the approach of the endgame of the insidious Individualism (Divide & Conquer) that has progressively rotted the psyche of the "Collective West"?

... asking for a friend ;) ...

Franz Kafka's avatar

Not to keep you without an answer for too long. I will repeat something I have heard: “All ‘isms’ stem from nihilism.”

Find ‘nihilism’ and you will have a workable answer. But why not ask Constantine - that is more his field than mine. However, I am going to think about your question as it is a good one and therefore already contains a part of the answer.

David Denny's avatar

Please don't steal my secret weapon !! --> another of my unanswered tantalisms is why every religion ends in -ism except that of the Christians, who choose themselves a suffix redolent of physical absolutes like gravity, quality, luminosity, ...

I will post you another tantalism: where is the overarching thing that mediates the different arms of postmodernism? All these isms have some sort of intellectual presidential cupola, it may be a god, a bunch of painters, a school of thought, but there is always a reference point. Does our Postmodernism have a guiding star, a government body, a Council of Trent?

Answers on a Pin Point.

"Postmodernity" lol, a postmodernity of 15 Kg/hour, a postmodernity of 15MeV/cc, a postmodernity between 1995/2025 and 2002/2025.

A kaleidoscope of the fragments of the shattered mirror of our great societies and religions, once broken, never restored. The Restorer has Left the Chat...

Thanks.

Franz Kafka's avatar

My 'like' does not begin to express my admiration for your eloquence and insight! Another idea, stemming from a simple etymological check is that Religion, is about restoration, coming as it does from the Latin 're'+ ligio' (to rebind) ...broken ties perhaps?

troy milton's avatar

Postmodernism legalized the will to power or natural selection through open boarders and soft on crime policy.

Modernism like the church imposed a set standard of civilization through reeducation.

Andrés Briceño's avatar

Good to know it wasn’t a complete waste of time reading a thousand plateau

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Aug 4, 2025
Comment deleted
David Denny's avatar

"And language? All is language and philosophy and semiotics of science: this primitive are the Anglosaxons! "

Poor Saxons, written out of their Nation by the Normans, and blamed for everything bad since by the Normans.

We fail to recognise the hooded Master of the Thousand-Year Norman Reich.

Poor Hitler was simply an uneducated fan of the Norman English dynasty, his transient success only from bankrolling by the hooded Cousins of the English Reich.

Why are we all so bamboozled by a cruel and relentless dynasty, perhaps at last, in these moments, now drawing its last foul breaths?