Constantin von Hoffmeister explains how a surprising left-right rapprochement and a possible cross-spectrum alliance against Germany’s corrupt liberal system is deepening the BSW’s internal split over closer engagement with the AfD.
The BSW, short for Bündnis Sahra Wagenknecht: Vernunft und Gerechtigkeit (Sahra Wagenknecht Alliance for Reason and Justice), is a new German political party founded on January8, 2024. It was created by Sahra Wagenknecht, a prominent left-wing politician (half-Iranian, half-German) born in 1969 in the former German Democratic Republic. Wagenknecht had long been a leading figure in Die Linke (The Left), a socialist party with roots in East German communism. She served as one of its co-leaders from 2015 to 2019 and spent many years in the national parliament.
Wagenknecht broke away because she believed the left had lost touch with ordinary working people. The modern left, she argued, focused too much on identity politics, open borders, gender debates, and climate symbolism while neglecting core economic issues such as wages, pensions, housing, and protection for small businesses. Many former left voters felt abandoned and turned instead to the AfD, the country’s main right-wing populist party. The BSW was meant to offer a different path: strong left-wing economic policies combined with more conservative and pragmatic stances on culture, immigration, and foreign affairs.
The party calls for higher minimum wages, stronger pensions, wealth taxes on the rich, and support for ordinary workers and small businesses. At the same time, it demands strict limits on immigration, criticizes rapid changes in language and gender policies, opposes green measures that sharply raise energy costs for families, and pushes for diplomacy and negotiations to end the war in Ukraine rather than indefinite military aid. It quickly gained traction in East Germany, where economic disappointment and cultural unease are widespread. In some 2024 state elections, the BSW achieved double-digit results. Nationally, however, it received only 4.9 percent in the February 2025 federal election, narrowly missing the 5 percent threshold for seats in parliament.
The Current Fight Inside the Party
Now the young party is tearing itself apart over a fundamental question. Read on to find out what it’s all about!
In the eastern state of Thuringia, about one hundred BSW members have published an open letter defending their national leaders’ willingness to hold public talks and possible cooperation with the AfD. Local Thuringian BSW officials have hit back hard, denouncing the signatories as “crackpots, fantasists and extremists.” The dispute centres on whether the BSW should continue working closely with the established “center-right” CDU (Christian Democratic Union, Chancellor Friedrich Merz’s party) or break old taboos and engage more openly with the AfD on shared concerns such as immigration control and the search for peace.
To grasp the conflict, one needs to understand Germany’s broader political system. After the Second World War, the country built what it called “safeguards against political extremes” (in reality censorship and state repression against uncomfortable political parties). The main parties—the fake “conservative” CDU, the centre-left (in reality, radically left) SPD (Social Democratic Party), the FDP (the Free Democratic Party, fake libertarians), and later the Greens—formed coalitions and kept “radicals” (sane parties) isolated. Die Linke represented the far left. For decades this center held.
The 2015 migrant crisis changed the picture. Large numbers of people arrived from the Middle East, Africa, and elsewhere. Many Germans worried about a strain on housing, schools, welfare, wages, and ethnocultural cohesion, as well as a massive rise in violent crime. The AfD, originally founded in 2013 as a Eurosceptic party critical of the euro and EU bailouts, shifted sharply rightward. It now calls for strict border controls, opposes what it sees as Islamization, favors welfare policies that prioritize German citizens, questions aggressive climate targets, and takes a more skeptical view of NATO and prolonged involvement in Ukraine. The party has become especially strong in East Germany, where many residents feel economically disadvantaged and culturally sidelined by politics dominated from the west.
Mainstream parties responded with a “firewall” (Brandmauer): an informal but powerful agreement never to form coalitions with the AfD or give it governing responsibility. They often avoid normal political dialogue as well. Defenders say the firewall protects democracy. Critics argue that excluding a party that regularly wins large vote shares in some regions only deepens alienation and blocks practical solutions. It is also deeply anti-democratic and some argue even tyrannical.
Where the BSW and AfD Overlap
Although the two parties come from opposite sides of the traditional spectrum, they share several concrete positions that matter to many voters. Both advocate much tighter immigration controls and open discussion of its effects on housing, wages, crime, and social trust. Both criticize endless arms deliveries to Ukraine without serious peace negotiations that takes the Russian side seriously. Both oppose green policies that drive up everyday living costs. Both present themselves as anti-establishment voices speaking for people ignored by the Berlin elite. These overlaps make some form of dialogue tempting, especially in eastern states where both draw protest votes. Traditional leftists see any contact as dangerous “legitimization.” Others say refusing to talk to a major party is itself undemocratic, which is obviously true for anybody with half a brain.
The Meaning of Querfront
The German term Querfront (cross-front or transverse front) refers to political cooperation or open debate that crosses the usual left–right divide. Historically, it recalls attempts in the Weimar Republic era to unite certain radical nationalists and socialists against the liberal center that betrayed the nation after World War One (just as it is betraying Germany today). Today, the word is most often used as an accusation. Critics claim the BSW is pursuing a risky Querfront strategy by softening its stance towards the AfD. Supporters answer that rigid firewalls prevent honest solutions to real problems and treat millions of citizens as political untouchables.
The Thuringia Conflict in Detail
In Thuringia, the BSW entered a governing coalition with the CDU. Katja Wolf, the BSW state leader, became Finance Minister under CDU Minister-President Mario Voigt (sometimes nicknamed after a local food, Mettbrötchen1). This gave the party real influence but damaged its image among voters who wanted confrontation with the old system rather than accommodation.
With state elections scheduled for September 2026, the national BSW leadership—including Amira Mohamed Ali, Fabio De Masi, and Sahra Wagenknecht—tried to correct course. They declared the party would no longer support the “firewall” parties that isolate the AfD. In states such as Saxony-Anhalt and Mecklenburg-Western Pomerania, they would back independent, non-party candidates for Minister-President who could form broad governments potentially including AfD ministers where this delivered stability and addressed voters’ concerns. They offered to debate these ideas publicly, including in direct formats such as Wagenknecht versus AfD co-leader Alice Weidel.
The Thuringian leadership reacted with fury. It preferred to remain in the CDU coalition. Stefan Wogawa, parliamentary manager of the Thuringian BSW group and a close ally of Wolf, accused the federal leaders of “cozying up to the AfD” and demanded their resignation.
The Open Letter
Roughly one hundred Thuringian BSW members answered with a public open letter. The signatories included two sitting state parliament members (Anke Wirsing and Sven Küntzel) and Anastasia Wirsing, federal chairwoman of the party’s youth organization. This gave the document real internal authority. The letter explained the disagreement in measured but firm language:
The public debate of recent days has shown that different views exist inside the BSW. This is natural and legitimate in a democratic party.
We are turning to the public because criticism by some members of the Thuringian parliamentary group has created the false impression that it reflects the position of the entire state association. We want to correct this.
We are among the members and supporters who back Sahra Wagenknecht’s proposal to consider an independent or cross-party viable candidate for the election for minister-president in Saxony-Anhalt if this can bring stability and a genuine new beginning to the state.
We likewise consider the federal executive’s invitation to Alice Weidel [leader of the AfD] for a public duel a legitimate democratic step. Whoever criticizes political positions should be ready to defend them in open debate. Democracy lives from public confrontation and the comparison of arguments.
By contrast, we see with concern that representatives of our Thuringian parliamentary group repeatedly turn such questions into public conflict with the federal executive. In our view, a state parliamentary group during an election campaign should do everything possible to support the common political success of the party.
Public conflicts with the federal leadership weaken the BSW’s credibility and distract attention from the political goals for which our party was founded. Different opinions should be discussed openly, respectfully, and above all in the proper party bodies. A variety of positions is an expression of internal party democracy. But internal democracy also requires clarity: public criticism by individual office-holders does not automatically speak for the entire state association.
With this open letter, we therefore wish to state clearly that numerous members and supporters of BSW Thuringia support the federal executive’s political course on the questions mentioned. We want a factual debate, mutual respect, and a common focus on what the citizens expect from us: sensible politics and unity on the decisive issues.
Oskar Lafontaine, Wagenknecht’s husband and a veteran socialist, further inflamed the debate by praising parts of the AfD’s foreign policy as “left-wing.”
Why the Struggle Is Important
The proposal from the national leadership of the BSW still contains gaps and half-measures. It does not call for full coalitions with the AfD everywhere. Yet it clearly signals a willingness to treat the AfD as a party one can argue with publicly rather than a permanent pariah. The open letter shows a real split inside the BSW. One wing seeks respectability by staying inside the old CDU-led system. The other believes genuine change requires breaking taboos, holding open debates, and addressing voters’ deepest practical concerns without fear of labels.
East Germany, with its particular history under communism, economic challenges, and greater distrust of distant elites, has become the main testing ground. The results of the September 2026 state elections there could decide whether the BSW becomes a lasting force capable of bridging some divides or fades away like earlier protest movements. The fight also tests a larger question for Germany: can a party successfully combine left-wing economics with pragmatic positions on immigration, culture, and peace, or will the old firewall and old coalitions continue to dominate? The open letter suggests that many inside the BSW still believe honest public argument and practical solutions matter more than rigid exclusion. The coming months will reveal which side prevails.
If you enjoy Constantin von Hoffmeister’s writing, order his new book, The Fate of White America, here.
Mettbrötchen is a popular German snack: a fresh bread roll topped with raw minced pork (called “Mett”), usually seasoned with onions, salt, pepper, and sometimes caraway or paprika. It’s a regional specialty in central and eastern Germany, similar to steak tartare on bread. In the article, it’s used as a folksy or mocking nickname for Thuringia’s CDU Minister-President Mario Voigt.



In a secural context casting a ballot is a liturgical act of submission. The individual is subconsciously saying, “I have done my part; the system is now responsible for the consequences.” It is a way to sleep at night while the world burns.
"The coming months will reveal which side prevails."
Most likely, just as in the US, the side that prevails will be the one that currently controls Germany now.